Craft Your Own Pizza or Calzone
- Small Pie / $10Hand tossed, freshly made dough, thin crust, and baked off on the stone. This is New York Pizza! 10 inch pizza. Italian Sausage, Pepperoni, Chicken Cutlet and Meatballs require an extra charge.
- Square Pie / $12Hand tossed, freshly made dough, thin crust, and baked off on the stone. This is New York Pizza! 13 inch pizza. Italian Sausage, Pepperoni, Chicken Cutlet, and Meatballs require an extra charge.
- Large Pie / $15Hand tossed, freshly made dough, thin crust and baked off on the stone. This is New York Pizza! 16 inch pizza . Italian Sausage, Pepperoni, Chicken Cutlet and Meatballs require an extra charge.
- Craft Your Own Calzone / $11This half moon turnover is stuffed with ricotta, mozzarella and your choice of toppings. Prepare to share! Additional toppings $1.25
Pizza by the Slice
now offering pizza by the slice!
- New York Style / $2.75Slice of any New York Style Pizza
- Specialty Pizza / $3.85A slice of any specialty pizza
- Margherita Pie - $13 / $18 / $23Classic pie with homemade sauce and shredded mozzarella.
- Pizza Alla Vodka - $13 / $18 / $23Created by the original Goodfellas in 1992, this pie was voted number one in America '94, '95 and is the winner of two national pizza contests. Fresh mozzarella, our famous vodka tomato cream sauce, seasoned fresh mushrooms, peas and prosciutto di parma.
- The Veggie Delight - $13 / $18 / $23Fresh mozzarella, our plum tomato sauce and 4 of any veggie toppings of your choice.
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza - $13 / $18 / $23Imported provolone, fresh mozzarella, creamy Buffalo sauce, breaded chicken and garnished with bruschetta tomatoes only at the world famous Goodfella's.
- The Goodfella Pizza - $13 / $18 / $23Fresh Mozzarella, our famous plum tomato sauce, topped with our very own brick oven roasted peppers, sausage and fresh sliced garlic. Choose size below:
- The Taco Pizza - $13/ $18/ $22Seasoned ground beef, refried beans, cheddar cheese, black olives and green onions.
- Cheeseburger Pizza - $13 / $18 / $22A delicious mix of ground beef, and all the fixins
- Hot Hawaiian - $13 / $ 18 / $22Canadian bacon, pineapple, BBQ sauce and jalepenos
12-inch individually made with imported Italian tomatoes and fresh mozzarella. Any pie can be made gluten free.
- Gluten-Free Pizza / $1212-inch individually made with imported Italian tomatoes and fresh mozzarella. Any pie can be made gluten free.
- Pepperoni, Fresh Garlic, Broccoli, Onions, Mushrooms, Green+ Red Peppers, Prosciutto, Sausage, Imported Provolone, Artichoke Hearts, Eggplant, Basil, Grilled Chicken, Black Olives, Ground Beef, Pineapple, Jalepenos, Candian Bacon
- New York Brick Oven Buffalo Wings / $9Classic hot wings drenched in our house made buffalo wing sauce. Bone-in and Bone-out available. Served with ranch or blue cheese
- Chicken Strips / $10Hand battered chicken breast strips served with house made ranch. Served with fries.
- Fried Ravioli / $9Goodfella's lightly breaded and fried fresh cheese ravioli, served with our famous marinara sauce.
- Mozzarella and Carrozza / $10Four House bread and mozzarella sandwiches, battered and fried, served with homemade marinara.
- Cheese Bread / $8Our original hand tossed dough brushed with garlic butter and covered with a pile of mozzarella. Finished with oregano and perfect for sharing.
- House Salad / $8House salad with Ranch dressing
- Nutella Pizza / $10Nutella and ricotta with a raspberry sauce drizzle and powdered sugar, a must try for the person with a sweet tooth!
- Tiramisu / $6Classic Italian dessert featuring Kahlua infused cake and a rich mascarpone cream sauce, finished with shaved dark chocolate and house whipped cream.
20 oz beverages
- Coke / $1.79
- Diet Coke / $1.79
- Sprite / $1.79
- Dr. Pepper / $1.79
- Fanta Orange / $1.79
- Dasani Water / $1.79
- Tummy Yummy Fruitabulous Punch / $1.25
- Peace Tea Caddyshack / $1.50
- Peace Tea Razzleberry / $1.50
- Nos Original / $2.49