• JudyPie Menu
Update Pick-Up Date & Time for Pies to Become Available!

JudyPie Menu

  • Daily Pie Menu

    24-HOUR TURNAROUND

    • Banana Pudding Pie
      Banana Pudding Pie
      Traditional banana pudding pie with a vanilla wafer crust. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
      • 10"
        ...................................................................................................
        $45
      • 6"
        ...................................................................................................
        $17
      • 4" (Includes one dozen)
        ...................................................................................................
        $75
    • Cherry Pie
      Cherry Pie
      Judy's cherry pie is made with red plump tart cherries and has a yummy light filling. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
      • 10"
        ...................................................................................................
        $45
      • 6"
        ...................................................................................................
        $17
      • 4" (Includes one dozen)
        ...................................................................................................
        $75
    • Cherry Merlot Pie
      Cherry Merlot Pie
      Judy's cherry pie is made with red plump tart cherries and a light filling with hints of merlot. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
      • 10"
        ...................................................................................................
        $45
      • 6"
        ...................................................................................................
        $17
      • 4" (Includes one dozen)
        ...................................................................................................
        $75
    • Chocolate Cream Pie
      Chocolate Cream Pie
      Made with semi-sweet creamy chocolate topped with whipped cream and chocolate shavings with a traditional crust. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
      • 10"
        ...................................................................................................
        $45
      • 6"
        ...................................................................................................
        $17
      • 4" (Includes one dozen)
        ...................................................................................................
        $75
    • Coconut Cream Pie
      Coconut Cream Pie
      50 yr old family recipe made with coconut and a traditional flaky crust. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
      • 10"
        ...................................................................................................
        $45
      • 6"
        ...................................................................................................
        $17
      • 4" (Include one dozen)
        ...................................................................................................
        $75
    • Creme Brûlée Pie
      Creme Brûlée Pie
      Irresistible Creme Brûlée Pie! This crowd-pleasing dessert perfectly imitates the velvety custard and caramelized sugar shell.
      • 10"
        ...................................................................................................
        $45
      • 6"
        ...................................................................................................
        $17
      • 4" (Includes one dozen)
        ...................................................................................................
        $75
    • Key Lime Pie
      Key Lime Pie
      Made with real Key limes inside a delicious graham cracker crust. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
      • 10"
        ...................................................................................................
        $45
      • 6"
        ...................................................................................................
        $17
      • 4" (Includes one dozen)
        ...................................................................................................
        $75
    • Memphis Mafia Pie
      Memphis Mafia Pie
      Graham cracker crust with several layers of chocolate ganache, peanut butter, banana, peanuts, Reese's pieces, chocolate, caramel, whipped cream, and bacon. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
      • 10"
        ...................................................................................................
        $45
      • 6"
        ...................................................................................................
        $17
      • 4" (Includes one dozen)
        ...................................................................................................
        $75
    • Rhoda's Chocolate Pecan Pie
      Rhoda's Chocolate Pecan Pie
      Traditional Pecan pie with chunks of chocolate and a flaky crust. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
      • 10"
        ...................................................................................................
        $45
      • 6"
        ...................................................................................................
        $17
      • 4" (Includes one dozen)
        ...................................................................................................
        $75
    • Rhoda's Pecan Pie
      Rhoda's Pecan Pie
      Traditional nutty pecan pie with a flaky crust. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM.
      • 10"
        ...................................................................................................
        $45
      • 6"
        ...................................................................................................
        $17
      • 4" (Includes one dozen)
        ...................................................................................................
        $75
    • Rhoda's Bourbon Pecan Pie
      Rhoda's Bourbon Pecan Pie
      Traditional nutty pecan pie with a flaky crust. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
      • 10"
        ...................................................................................................
        $45
      • 6"
        ...................................................................................................
        $17
      • 4" (Includes one dozen)
        ...................................................................................................
        $75
    • Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
      Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
      Sweet strawberries married with a sour rhubarb and a traditional crust. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
      • 10"
        ...................................................................................................
        $45
      • 6"
        ...................................................................................................
        $17
      • 4" (Includes one dozen)
        ...................................................................................................
        $75
    • Dirty Judy
      Dirty Judy
      Dense, Rich, Chocolate! Everything good about the world in a pie! It’s got the looks of a disaster, but the taste of a gourmet meal!
      • 10"
        ...................................................................................................
        $45
      • 6"
        ...................................................................................................
        $17
      • 4" (Includes one dozen)
        ...................................................................................................
        $75
    • Apple Lattice
      Apple Lattice
      Our traditional apple filling with a golden lattice top
      • 10"
        ...................................................................................................
        $45
    • Ghirardelli Flourless Chocolate Torte
      Ghirardelli Flourless Chocolate Torte
      Ghirardelli Flourless Chocolate Torte. A dense rich chocolate flour free pie.
      • 10"
        ...................................................................................................
        $45
      • 6"
        ...................................................................................................
        $17
      Gluten Free
  • 3 Day Turnaround Pies

    3-DAY TURNAROUND

    • Red Velvet Pie
      Red Velvet Pie
      A red velvet cake with a short bread crust and traditional cream cheese frosting. Pick-Up Info: 3-day turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
      • 10"
        ...................................................................................................
        $45
    • German Chocolate
      German Chocolate
      Made with layers of dense chocolate topped with coconut and a caramel inside a shortbread crust. Pick-Up Info: 3 day turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
      • 10"
        ...................................................................................................
        $45
    •  Lemon Chess
      Lemon Chess
      A rich lemony, buttery-filling pie, passed down from my great Grandmother. It was said that she would create the pie, and the men would gather and play chess.
      • 10"
        ...................................................................................................
        $45
    • Adohree-A-Doodle Pie
      Adohree-A-Doodle Pie
      Judy's favorite pie is made with Adohree's secret Snickerdoodle recipe, and is named after her daughter, Adohree. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
      • 10"
        ...................................................................................................
        $45
    • Blueberry Ginger
      Blueberry Ginger
      Made with fresh blueberries and ginger Pick up Info: 3-day turnaround with pick up available after 11 AM
      • 10"
        ...................................................................................................
        $45
    • Maple Bourbon Peach
      Maple Bourbon Peach
      • 10"
        ...................................................................................................
        $45
    • Punky Pumpkin Pie
      Punky Pumpkin Pie
      Traditional Pumpkin Pie with a flaky crust.
      • 10"
        ...................................................................................................
        $45
    • Buttermilk Pie
      Buttermilk Pie
      Just a sweet creamy naked pie that we guarantee tastes just like your Grandmother's. Shipped in a lovely tin can. Include recipients name, & address and we will do the rest. Enclosure card included. Please note address on special instructions. Price includes shipping. Discounts available for 50 or more.
      • 10"
        ...................................................................................................
        $45
    • Apple Crumble Pie
      Apple Crumble Pie
      Made with plump Granny Smith apples topped with a sweet apple crumble. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
      • 10"
        ...................................................................................................
        $45
      • 6"
        ...................................................................................................
        $17
      • 4" (Includes one dozen)
        ...................................................................................................
        $75
    • Raspberry Rose
      Raspberry Rose
      Made with a cream cheese filling, raspberry puree inside a graham cracker crust topped with whipped cream. Pick-Up Info: 3-day turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
      • 10"
        ...................................................................................................
        $45
      • 6"
        ...................................................................................................
        $17
      • 4" (Includes one dozen)
        ...................................................................................................
        $75
    • Pumpkin Roll
      Pumpkin Roll
      Pick-Up Info: 24 hours turnaround with pick-up available after 12 PM.
      $29.95
    • Keto, GF, & Vegan Cheesecake Menu

      24 hour notice for Gluten Free Cheesecake. *All other GF - 3 weeks

      • Gluten Free Whole Reese's Cheesecake
        Gluten Free Whole Reese's Cheesecake
        Rich and delicious 10 inch Gluten Free Reese's Cheesecake. Melts in your mouth.
        $79
          Gluten Free
        • Gluten Free Whole NY Cheesecake
          Gluten Free Whole NY Cheesecake
          Introducing our newest addition to our menu, the gluten-free cheesecake. Made with a dense and creamy filling using real cream cheese, this classic dessert is the perfect way to end any meal. Our gluten-free option ensures that everyone can enjoy a delicious dessert without compromising their dietary needs. Share a slice with someone who is gluten-free and delight in the rich and satisfying taste of our cheesecake. Treat yourself to a guilt-free indulgence today.
          $79
            Gluten Free
          • Gluten Free Whole Key Lime Cheesecake
            Gluten Free Whole Key Lime Cheesecake
            Our creamy cheesecake married key limes, and created a sweet dessert with just the right amount of tang. Made with the freshest ingredients, our Gluten Free Key Lime cheesecake features a creamy filling that's rich in flavor and silky smooth in texture. Enjoy every bite as a mouth-watering experience, that will have you coming back for more. Share with your gluten free friends, they will love you.
            $79
              Gluten Free
          • Cake Menu

            TURNAROUND VARIES DEPENDING ON THE CAKE! PLEASE READ THE CAKE DESCRIPTION FOR MORE INFO!

            • German Chocolate Cake
              German Chocolate Cake
              Made from scratch, our take on the classic german chocolate cake topped with coconut and pecans. Pick-Up Info: 3 day turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM Serves 8-10.
              $65
              • Carrot Cake
                Carrot Cake
                All fresh ingredients and made from scratch. Not only does it taste delicious, but is equally beautiful! Serves 8-10. Pick-Up Info: 3 day turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
                $65
                • Vanilla Bean Cheesecake
                  Vanilla Bean Cheesecake
                  Delicious, dense cheesecake-flavored cake topped with rich icing and flakes. Pick-Up Info: 3 day turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
                  $69.99
                  • Chocolate Pudding Cake
                    Chocolate Pudding Cake
                    Delicious, dense chocolate cake topped with rich icing and chocolate curls. Pick-Up Info: 3 day turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
                    $69.99
                    • Custom Dog Cakes
                      Custom Dog Cakes
                      Celebrate your pup's birthday with a yummy cake! Please include what you would like written on your cake in the notes section on the checkout page.
                      $29.95
                      • Red Velvet
                      • Banana
                      • Pumpkin Spice
                      • Birthday Cake
                      • Select One
                    • Red Velvet Cake
                      Red Velvet Cake
                      Made from scratch, this southern classic and Ophrah's favorite is smooth velvet with a mild chocolate flavor. Serves 8-10. Pick-Up Info: 24 hours turnaround with pick-up available after 12 PM
                      $65
                      • Tiramisu
                        Tiramisu
                        Made of sponge cake dipped in coffee, layered with a whipped mixture of eggs, sugar and mascarpone and flavored with cocoa. Pick-Up Info: 3 day turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM Serves 8-10.
                        $75
                      • Cookies, Hand Pies, & More Menu

                        24-HOUR TURNAROUND

                        • Hand Pies | Half a Dozen
                          Hand Pies | Half a Dozen
                          Half a dozen sweet hand pies filled with flavors like Apple, Cherry, Lemon Raspberry, or Peach. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
                          $45
                          • Apple
                          • Cherry
                          • Lemon Raspberry
                          • Peach
                          • Pecan
                          • Pumpkin Spice
                        • Stickie Buns | Half a Dozen
                          Stickie Buns | Half a Dozen
                          Half a dozen delicious fluffy stickie buns. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM.
                          $27
                          • Stickie Bun
                          • Cinnamon Roll
                        • Cookies | Half a Dozen
                          Cookies | Half a Dozen
                          Half a dozen of delicious in-house-made cookies. Flavors include Blueberry Lemon, Skillet, Chocolate Chunk, M&M, Peanut Butter, Snickerdoodle, Raspberry Cream, or White Chocolate Macadamia. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM
                          $25
                          • Snickerdoodle
                          • M&M
                          • Peanut Butter
                          • Chocolate Chunk
                          • Skillet
                          • Blueberry Lemon
                          • White Chocolate Macadamia Nut
                          • Raspberry Lemon
                        •  Cinnamon Rolls | Half a Dozen
                          Cinnamon Rolls | Half a Dozen
                          Half a dozen delicious fluffy cinnamon rolls. Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM.
                          $27
                          • Stickie Bun
                          • Cinnamon Roll
                        • Strawberry Whipped Cream Roll
                          Strawberry Whipped Cream Roll
                          Pick-Up Info: 2-day turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM.
                          $29.95
                          • Baileys Strawberry Whipped Cream Roll
                            Baileys Strawberry Whipped Cream Roll
                            *Alcohol infused* Pick-Up Info: 2-day turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM.
                            $29.95
                          • Pie It Forward Menu

                            24-HOUR TURNAROUND

                            • Pie It Forward
                              Pie It Forward
                              Let your recipient select any flavor when the gift is picked up! Pick-Up Info: 24-hour turnaround with pick-up available after 11 AM.
                              • Slice of Pie
                                ...................................................................................................
                                $9
                              • 6"
                                ...................................................................................................
                                $17
                              • 10"
                                ...................................................................................................
                                $45