• Main Menu
  • Drinks
  • Easter Baskets
(GF) - Indicates a Gluten Free Dish. The Southern Lilly takes a lot of pride in providing food to our community that is made from scratch using fresh, quality ingredients. Please ask about our daily specials by calling the store (719-896-1053) and don't be afraid to ask for something customized to your tastes.

Main Menu

  • Appetizers

    Other appetizers may be available please ask your server!

    • Pork Rinds (GF)
      Pork Rinds (GF)
      Fresh fried pork rinds tossed in your choice of Cajun, lemon pepper, or honey Chipotle seasoning and served with cheese dip.
      $9
        Gluten Free
      • Fried Pickles
        Fried Pickles
        Dill pickles hand battered and fried to order, served with ranch
        $8
          Gluten Free
        • Crab Dip
          Crab Dip
          Crab meat mixed with Pepper Jack, Cream Cheese, Scallions, Celery, Fresh Garlic, Red Onion, and Cajun Seasoning baked to order. Served with Toasted Bread and mixed Vegetables
          $14
        • Breads

          Freshly baked breads

          • Cast Iron Skillet Cornbread
            Cast Iron Skillet Cornbread
            A sweet and smokey cornbread batter made in house and baked to order in a 7 inch cast iron skillet. Served with butter or honey. Takes about 10 minutes but well worth the wait!
            $5
              Gluten Free
            • Buttermilk Biscuits
              Buttermilk Biscuits
              4 Freshly baked buttermilk biscuits served with honey or butter
              $3
            • Fresh Salads

              Dressing Choices: Ranch, Bleu Cheese, Balsamic Vinaigrette, & Thousand Island

              • Chef Salad
                Chef Salad
                Spring Mix Lettuce, Smoked Turkey Breast, Ham, a Hard Boiled Egg, Cherry Tomatoes, Cucumber, Swiss Cheese, and Cheddar
                $13
                  Gluten Free
                • House Salad
                  A generous portion of Spring Mix Lettuce, topped with Cherry Tomatoes, Red Onion, Shredded Cheddar, and House Made Croutons
                  $7
                • Elk Chili

                  • Elk Chili (GF)
                    Elk Chili (GF)
                    Our Award-Winning Elk Chili is made with locally sourced Elk, a mix of Sweet and Spicy pork sausages, and a warm and zesty blend of spices. Garnished with Cheddar Cheese and Chives. Cup: $7 or Bowl: $14
                    $14
                      Gluten Free
                    • Loaded Baked Potato (GF)
                      Loaded Baked Potato (GF)
                      A large Baked Potato smothered in Elk Chili and topped with Cheddar Cheese and Chives.
                      $14
                        Gluten Free
                      • Chili Cheese Fries (GF)
                        Your choice of house cut French-fries or sweet potato fries covered in our elk chili and topped with melted cheddar cheese and chives.
                        $15
                          Gluten Free
                        • Elk Chili Melt
                          Elk Chili Melt
                          Our Best Seller! Cast iron skillet layered with Cornbread Batter, Elk Chili, and shredded Sharp Cheddar. Baked to order and topped with fresh Chives.
                          $13
                            Gluten Free
                          • Chili Mac
                            Our house made Mac and Cheese and Elk Chili baked together
                            $13
                          • Mac N Cheese

                            Cavatappi Pasta with a Rich, Creamy Cheddar Cheese Sauce.

                            • Build Your Own
                              Cavatappi Pasta with a rich, creamy Cheddar Cheese Sauce Cup: $5 Bowl: $9
                              $9
                              • Bacon
                                ...................................................................................................
                                $1
                              • Chicken (Fried or Grilled)
                                ...................................................................................................
                                $4
                              • Crawfish
                                ...................................................................................................
                                $4
                              • Hamburger
                                ...................................................................................................
                                $4
                              • Smoked Turkey Breast
                                ...................................................................................................
                                $4
                              • Vegetarian (Spinach & Tomatoes)
                                ...................................................................................................
                                $3
                              • Grilled Onions
                                ...................................................................................................
                                $1
                              • Chives
                                ...................................................................................................
                                $0.75
                              • Red Onion
                                ...................................................................................................
                                $0.50
                              • Ham
                                ...................................................................................................
                                $4
                              • Andouille Sausage
                                ...................................................................................................
                                $4
                              • Fried Egg
                                ...................................................................................................
                                $1
                          • Sandwiches

                            • The Kentucky Hot Brown
                              Toasted Texas Toast and Smoked Turkey Breast topped with a Creamy Parmesan Sauce, Bacon, and Sliced Tomato baked in a cast iron skillet
                              $14
                              • Po'Boy
                                Po'Boy
                                Served on a 6 inch Toasted Hoagie Roll, with Spring Mix and tomato with your choice of sauce on the bread. Fried Chicken Po'Boy Pictured
                                • Fried Crawfish
                                  ...................................................................................................
                                  $16
                                • Chicken (Fried or Grilled)
                                  ...................................................................................................
                                  $14
                                • Shrimp (Grilled or Fried)
                                  ...................................................................................................
                                  $14
                                • Roast Beef
                                  ...................................................................................................
                                  $13
                              • Burger
                                Classic 1/2 pound all Beef Patty seasoned and formed in house and cooked to order. Served on a Crystola bun, a European style bread that is lower in gluten than most and very light, NOT GLUTEN FREE
                                $12
                                • Cheddar Cheese
                                  ...................................................................................................
                                  $1
                                • Swiss Cheese
                                  ...................................................................................................
                                  $1
                                • Pepper Jack
                                  ...................................................................................................
                                  $1
                                • Bleu Cheese
                                  ...................................................................................................
                                  $1
                                • Grilled Onions
                                  ...................................................................................................
                                  $1
                                • Pickled Jalapenos
                                  ...................................................................................................
                                  $0.50
                                • Elk Chili
                                  ...................................................................................................
                                  $2
                                • Bacon
                                  ...................................................................................................
                                  $1
                                • Fried Egg
                                  ...................................................................................................
                                  $1
                                • Crab Cheese
                                  ...................................................................................................
                                  $3
                                • Blackening
                                  ...................................................................................................
                                  $0.25
                            • Entrees a La Carte

                              • Fried Chicken
                                Fried Chicken
                                Our Fried Chicken is marinated in buttermilk and hand breaded to order in a house mix of seasonings and Rice Flour FULL ORDER 4 Strips of Breast Meat OR 2 Pieces of Thigh Meat HALF ORDER 2 Strips of Breast Meat OR 1 Piece of Thigh Meat
                                • Full Order
                                  ...................................................................................................
                                  $9
                                • Half Order
                                  ...................................................................................................
                                  $4.50
                                Gluten Free
                              • Chicken and Biscuits
                                Full or Half order of Fried Chicken with Buttermilk Biscuits smothered in House Made Sausage Gravy
                                • Full Order of Fried Chicken and Two Buttermilk Biscuits
                                  ...................................................................................................
                                  $15
                                • Half Order of Fried Chicken and One Buttermilk Biscuit
                                  ...................................................................................................
                                  $10
                              • Biscuits and Gravy
                                FULL ORDER 2 open faced Buttermilk Biscuits smothered in our house made Sausage Gravy HALF ORDER 1 open faced Buttermilk Biscuit Smothered in our house made Sausage Gravy
                                • Full Order
                                  ...................................................................................................
                                  $9
                                • Half Order
                                  ...................................................................................................
                                  $6
                              • Grilled Salmon
                                8 oz Grilled Salmon fillet with Herb Butter and a slice of Lemon
                                $14
                                  Gluten Free
                                • Meatloaf
                                  Served with Brown Gravy
                                  $12
                                    Gluten Free
                                • Sides

                                  • Vegetable of the Day
                                    $4.75
                                      Gluten Free
                                    • Mashed Potatoes (GF)
                                      $4.75
                                        Gluten Free
                                      • French Fries (GF)
                                        $4.75
                                          Gluten Free
                                        • Fried Okra (GF)
                                          $4.75
                                            Gluten Free
                                          • Sweet Potato Fries (GF)
                                            $4.75
                                              Gluten Free
                                            • Baked Potato (GF)
                                              A Russet potato baked to tenderness and served with butter.
                                              $4.75
                                              • Sour Cream, Bacon, & Chives
                                                ...................................................................................................
                                                $3
                                              Gluten Free
                                          • Kid’s Menu

                                            (Served with a drink and one side choice)

                                            • Southern Lilly's Fried Chicken (GF)
                                              Two strips of chicken breast, hand breaded and fried to order
                                              $9
                                                Gluten Free
                                              • Grilled Cheese Sammich
                                                Toasted Texas toast and melted white cheddar cheese
                                                $9
                                                • Kid's Cheeseburger
                                                  Small Cheeseburger cooked to order
                                                  $9
                                                  • Sides
                                                    Included with Kids Entree Vegetable of the Day, Mashed Potatoes, French Fries, Sweet Potato Fries, Fried Okra
                                                    • Drinks
                                                      Included with Kids Entree Milk, Apple Juice, Pineapple Juice, Coke Products, Sweet Tea, Unsweet Tea
                                                    • Desserts

                                                      • Chocolate Chip Cookie Bake Topped with Ice Cream
                                                        A freshly made to order, still gooey house baked chocolate chip cookie topped with vanilla ice cream. (Takes 10 minutes)
                                                        $7
                                                        • Cast Iron Cobbler of the Day
                                                          Baked to order, ask your server for the flavor of the day
                                                          $7
                                                          • Scoop of Vanilla Ice Cream
                                                            ...................................................................................................
                                                            $2
                                                      • Drinks

                                                        • Pop
                                                          Coke, Diet Coke, Pibb Xtra, Sprite, Barq's Root Beer
                                                          $3.25
                                                          • Coke
                                                          • Diet Coke
                                                          • Sprite
                                                          • Pibb Xtra
                                                          • Barq’s Root Beer
                                                          • Lemonade
                                                        • Real Southern Sweet or Unsweetened Tea
                                                          Brewed fresh daily and sweetened with pure Cane Sugar
                                                          $3
                                                          • Add Peach, Mango, or Raspberry syrup
                                                            ...................................................................................................
                                                            $1
                                                        • Arnold Palmer
                                                          Made with our Lemonade and your choice of Sweet or Unsweet Tea
                                                          $3.50
                                                          • Add Peach, Mango, or Raspberry syrup
                                                            ...................................................................................................
                                                            $1
                                                        • Hot Teas
                                                          Your choice of an assortment of individually wrapped teas. Lemon, assortment of sweetners, and cream are also available upon request.
                                                          $3
                                                          • Add Peach, Mango, or Raspberry syrup
                                                            ...................................................................................................
                                                            $1
                                                        • Juice
                                                          $2.50
                                                          • Cranberry
                                                          • Apple
                                                        • Whole Milk
                                                          $2.50
                                                          • Coffee
                                                            Brewed from fresh-ground organic Equal Exchange whole bean coffee
                                                            $2.50
                                                            • Decaf
                                                            • Caffeine
                                                          • Lemonade
                                                            Made in house with hand squeezed Lemons and sweetened with pure Cane Sugar
                                                            $3.50
                                                            • Flavored Teas
                                                              Raspberry, Peach, or Mango
                                                              $4
                                                            • Main Menu
                                                            • Drinks
                                                            • Easter Baskets

                                                            Drinks

                                                            • Coca-Cola Products - $2.95

                                                              Coke • Diet Coke • Sprite • Pibb Xtra • Barq’s Root Beer • Orange Fanta

                                                            • Lemonade or Arnold Palmer - $2.95

                                                            • Teas

                                                              • Sugar Free or Southern Sweet
                                                                $2.95
                                                                • Flavored Teas
                                                                  $3.95
                                                                  • Flavors: Mango, Peach, Lemon, Lime, Pear-Mint, Raspberry Mint.
                                                                • Hot Tea
                                                                  Ask your server to see our selection of regular or decaffeinated options. Half & Half upon request.
                                                                  $2.50
                                                                • Coffee - $2.50

                                                                  Made from freshly-ground, organic, Equal-Exchange beans. Regular or Decaffeinated.

                                                                • Juice - $2.50 (no free-refills)

                                                                  Cranberry • Apple

                                                                • Milk - $2.50

                                                                  Organic 2% Milk

                                                                • Main Menu
                                                                • Drinks
                                                                • Easter Baskets
                                                                This year we're giving you back your Holiday dinner with our house-made Southern Favorites! Order over the phone or send us a message!

                                                                Easter Baskets