Specializing in beautiful, all natural wedding cakes and hand crafted pastries, Proper Pastry is the premier destination for gourmet baked goods in Northeast Indiana.

Wedding Cakes
Beautiful and Delicious Scratch Made Wedding Cake
- Custom Wedding Cake
  Our wedding cakes are scratch made from premium ingredients and topped with Italian Buttercream Icing. Please schedule your appointment with Chef Anna today! Our cake flavors include vanilla, chocolate, lemon, red velvet, carrot, pistachio, almond, coconut, hazelnut, strawberry, raspberry, and Banana. Our buttercream fillings and are vanilla, chocolate, lemon, almond, coconut, pistachio, hazelnut, raspberry, strawberry. Our cream cheese fillings and frostings are regular, lemon, almond, coconut. Other fillings include raspberry preserves, strawberry preserves, chocolate ganache, lemon curd. Our cakes are 3 layers of cake and two layers of filling. Contact us for pricing via phone, text, or email!
- Cake Tasting
  Cake tastings are available at your convenience. Simply call or email Anna 48 hours before you would like to schedule a tasting. All tastings are $20 and include 3 different fillings and frostings of your choice. Additional samples may be requested for $2.50 each. Pay Online and then Call or Email Chef Anna to schedule your appointment! Phone 260-413-5203 Email: Anna@properpastry.com
  $20
- Sweets Table
  Ask about the variety of complementary sweets available. You may find that in addition to a beautiful and flavorful wedding cake you can surprise and delight your guests with world class pastries and baked goods.
All Occasion Cakes
Custom Cakes for any occasion!
- All Occasion Cake
  Custom prepared for your special event.
Macarons & Brownie Bombs
Little bites of Heaven!
- Assorted Macarons - One Dozen
  This beauty is two soft cookies with Italian Buttercream Icing holding it all together. Made with almond flour these morsels are free from ingredients containing gluten. Assorted Flavors Available. Order Size - One Dozen. Individual Servings available at the shop - $2.25 each
  $25
- Chocolate Mousse Brownie Bomb/ One Dozen
  Somewhere between pastry and a chocolate truffle, you will find the Chocolate Mousse Brownie Bomb. You will then realize that Brownie Bombs are what is missing from your life. Order Size - One Dozen. Individual Servings available at the shop - $3.
  $36
Croissants
Savory or Sweet Croissants are the perfect addition to any meal!
- Plain Butter Croissant - Half Dozen
  Simple, buttery and flaky. Single Croissants available in store for $4.00 each.
  $20
- Chocolate Croissant - Half Dozen
  The buttery crescent with semi-sweet chocolate batons. Individual Servings available in store - $5.25
  $28
- Almond Cream Croissant - Half Dozen
  Our tasty buttery croissant filled with rich almond cream. Individual servings available in store - $5.75
  $30
- Berry Cheesecake Croissant- Half Dozen
  A classic pastry with roots in Denmark. This flaky pastry is a great sweet treat to start your day. Individual Servings available in store - $5.85
  $30
- Prosciutto & Cheddar Croissant - Half Dozen
  Adding delicious prosciutto and the rich nutty flavor of Cheddar cheese is a delightful addition to our buttery croissants. Individual Servings available in store - $6.
  $36
- Vegetarian Croissant - Half Dozen
  Filled with Spinach, Red Pepper, and Feta Cheese so everyone can enjoy a savory breakfast delicacy. Individual servings available in store - $5. Mushroom Brie filled croissant. Mushroom Duxelle and double cream brie wrapped in buttery pastry - $6
  $30
- Cheddar Croissant - Half Dozen
  A flaky, buttery croissant with the perfect amount of cheddar to give it a little zip. Individual servings available in store - $6
  $28
- Bear Claw/ Half Dozen
  Vanilla bean pastry cream filled croissant with an oatmeal crumble and cinnamon glaze. 5.75 each
  $30
Artisan Bread
Tasty Scratch Made Loaves with Non-GMO Organic Wheat Flower
- Sourdough Bread
  Natural fermentation gives this crowd favorite a slightly sour taste. Native recipes from many different countries and recipes shared through generations ensure that each sourdough bread recipe is unique. Made with Non-GMO organic flour.
  $9
- Sourdough Rye
  This German style sourdough rye has a rustic crust and soft interior with a delicious hint of sour rye. Made with organic, Non-GMO flours.
  $10
Gluten Sensitive
Removing gluten from your diet doesn't mean that you have to give up on delicious pastries and baked goods. Rather than using imitations and substitutions, Chef Anna designs these treats with naturally gluten free ingredients. Chosen for there unique flavors and wonderful textures, these ingredients were Chef Anna's first choice. There is nothing "missing" from these pastries and we think you'll agree. Due to the nature of our process and our kitchen, we cannot guarantee that these products have not been exposed to or stored with items containing gluten.
- Raspberry Almond Flax Bar - One Dozen
  A warm toasty flavor and a moist chewy texture surrounds the raspberry jam that is at the heart of this gem. Order Size - One Dozen. Individual servings available at the shop - $6 each
  $65
- Apricot Almond Flax Bar - One Dozen
  Apricot Jam enveloped by almond flour & flax seed with hints of caramelized sugar. Order Size - One Dozen. Individual Servings available at the Store - $6
  $65
- Assorted Macarons - One Dozen
  This beauty is two soft cookies with Italian Buttercream Icing holding it all together. Made with almond flour these morsels are free of ingredients containing gluten. Request a custom batch with jam filling and you have yourself a gluten free, dairy free piece of heaven. Order Size - One Dozen. Individual Servings available at the shop - $2.25
  $25
  - Custom Order - Single Flavor
    $3
- Custom Creations - Gluten Free Ingredients
  Chef Anna's creativity and knowledge are boundless. Contact Proper Pastry to discuss a creation crafted with naturally gluten free ingredients just for you.
- Biscotti
  Almond and sesame seed honeycomb biscotti. Aside from not having wheat flour, these tasty treats are also dairy free. $40 per dozen
  $4
Brioche, Cinnamon Rolls, and Donuts
Delicious, fresh, yeasted rolls made with the finest flours and ingredients.
- Cinnamon Rolls
  Buttery, tender yeast rolls filled with brown sugar and cinnamon, Glazed with a light vanilla cream cheese frosting.
  $4.25
- Filled brioche rolls
  Buttery French bread filled with almond custard and topped with fresh berries or cherries.
  $5.85
- Yeast Donuts
  Delicate crumb baked donuts. Vanilla glaze, cinnamon sugar, raspberry jam filled, and donut holes.
  $4.25

Specializing in beautiful, all natural wedding cakes and hand crafted pastries, Proper Pastry is the premier destination for gourmet baked goods in Northeast Indiana.

Macarons & Brownie Bombs
Little Bites of Heaven!
- Assorted Macarons - One Dozen
  This beauty is two soft cookies with Italian Buttercream Icing holding it all together. Made with almond flour these morsels are free of ingredients containing gluten. Request a custom batch with jam filling and you have yourself a gluten free, dairy free piece of heaven. Order Size - One Dozen. Individual Servings available at the shop - $2.25
  $25
  - Custom Order - Single Flavor
    $3
- Chocolate Mousse Brownie Bomb/ One Dozen
  Somewhere between pastry and a chocolate truffle, you will find the Chocolate Mousse Brownie Bomb. You will then realize that Brownie Bombs are what is missing from your life. Order Size - One Dozen. Individual Servings available at the shop - $3.
  $36
Croissants
Savory or Sweet Croissants are the perfect addition to any meal!
- Plain Butter Croissant - Half Dozen
  Simple, buttery and flaky. Single Croissants available in store for $4.00 each.
  $20
- Chocolate Croissant - Half Dozen
  The buttery crescent with semi-sweet chocolate batons. Individual Servings available in store - $5.25
  $28
- Almond Cream Croissant - Half Dozen
  Our tasty buttery croissant filled with rich almond cream. Individual servings available in store - $5.75
  $30
- Prosciutto & Cheddar Croissant - Half Dozen
  Adding delicious prosciutto and the rich nutty flavor of Cheddar cheese is a delightful addition to our buttery croissants. Individual Servings available in store - $6.
  $36
- Vegetarian Croissant - Half Dozen
  Filled with Spinach, Red Pepper, and Feta Cheese so everyone can enjoy a savory breakfast delicacy. Individual servings available in store - $5. Mushroom Brie filled croissant. Mushroom Duxelle and double cream brie wrapped in buttery pastry - $6
  $30
- Cheddar Croissant - Half Dozen
  A flaky, buttery croissant with the perfect amount of cheddar to give it a little zip. Individual servings available in store - $6
  $28
- Berry Cheesecake Croissant- Half Dozen
  A classic pastry with roots in Denmark. This flaky pastry is a great sweet treat to start your day. Individual Servings available in store - $5.85
  $30
Artisan Bread
Tasty Scratch Made Loaves with Non-GMO Organic Wheat Flower
- Sourdough Bread
  Natural fermentation gives this crowd favorite a slightly sour taste. Native recipes from many different countries and recipes shared through generations ensure that each sourdough bread recipe is unique. Made with Non-GMO organic flour.
  $9
- Baguette
  A french classic with a wonderful texture and crisp crust, this bread will make a regular appearance on your table.
  $6.50
- Sourdough Rye
  This German style sourdough rye has a rustic crust and soft interior with a delicious hint of sour rye. Made with organic, Non-GMO flours.
  $10
Gluten Sensitive
Removing gluten from your diet doesn't mean that you have to give up on delicious pastries and baked goods. Rather than using imitations and substitutions, Chef Anna designs these treats with naturally gluten free ingredients. Chosen for there unique flavors and wonderful textures, these ingredients were Chef Anna's first choice. There is nothing "missing" from these pastries and we think you'll agree. Due to the nature of our process and our kitchen, we cannot guarantee that these products have not been exposed to or stored with items containing gluten.
- Raspberry Almond Flax Bar - One Dozen
  A warm toasty flavor and a moist chewy texture surrounds the raspberry jam that is at the heart of this gem. Order Size - One Dozen. Individual servings available at the shop - $6 each
  $65
- Apricot Almond Flax Bar - One Dozen
  Apricot Jam enveloped by almond flour & flax seed with hints of caramelized sugar. Order Size - One Dozen. Individual Servings available at the Store - $6
  $65
- Assorted Macarons - One Dozen
  This beauty is two soft cookies with Italian Buttercream Icing holding it all together. Made with almond flour these morsels are free of ingredients containing gluten. Request a custom batch with jam filling and you have yourself a gluten free, dairy free piece of heaven. Order Size - One Dozen. Individual Servings available at the shop - $2.25
  $25
  - Custom Order - Single Flavor
    $3
Wedding Cakes
Beautiful and Delicious Scratch Made Wedding Cakes
- Cake Tasting
  Cake tastings are available at your convenience. Simply call or email Anna 48 hours before you would like to schedule a tasting. All tastings are $20 and include 3 different fillings and frostings of your choice. Additional samples may be requested for $2.50 each. Pay Online and then Call or Email Chef Anna to schedule your appointment! Phone 260-413-5203 Email: Anna@properpastry.com
  $20

Wedding Cakes

All Occasion Cakes

Macarons & Brownie Bombs

Croissants

Artisan Bread

Gluten Sensitive

Brioche, Cinnamon Rolls, and Donuts

Macarons & Cookies

Almond Flax Bars

Custom Creations for the Gluten Sensitive

Wedding Cakes Fort Wayne

Macarons & Brownie Bombs

Croissants

Artisan Bread

Gluten Sensitive

Wedding Cakes