What makes a pub “proper?”
appetizers
- Spinach Artichoke Dip$12.95Served with Proper fries
- Proper Fries$7.95Served with sage sauce
- Scotch Egg$11.95Two hard-boiled eggs wrapped in sausage, lightly breaded and deep fried, served with Mac’s creamy sage sauce
- Pretzels Bites$6.95Salted or unsalted, served with cheese sauce
- Fried Brie$11.95Breaded and fried, served with chutney and grilled French bread
- Mac’s Loaded Tots$9.95Large basket of Mac’s classic tater tots topped with cheese, scallions, and bacon
- Sauerkraut Balls$9.95Sauerkraut, hot Italian sausage, cheddar cheese, and herbs served with horseradish ranch
- Chicken Wings$11.95A pound of wings with celery, ranch or bleu cheese, BBQ, sweet chili, buffalo, chipotle, or No Refund Hot
- Chicken Fingers$8.95Served with honey mustard
starters and soups
- Smoked Salmon Toast$9.95Smoked salmon, dill cream cheese, rye toast, and red onion
- Buffalo Shrimp$11.95Sautéd jumbo shrimp tossed in buffalo sauce served with celery and bleu cheese or ranch
- Charcuterie Platter$16.95Assorted cured meats and cheeses with chutney, dijon, and French bread
- Chili$5.95Mac’s homemade chili, covered with cheddar cheese, and diced red onions
- Soup of the Day$5.95Chef’s whim
- Guinness Stew$6.95Hearty beef stew made with Ireland’s finest stout and Ohio’s finest beef, celery, carrots, and onions
salads
Add to any salad: Chicken $4.95 / Salmon or Shrimp $7.95 / Portabella $4.95 Dressings: Balsamic Vinaigrette, Sherry Vinaigrette, Caesar, Honey Mustard, Golden Italian, Bleu Cheese, Horseradish Ranch
- House Salad$8.95Mixed greens, feta, red onions, cucumbers, bacon, red onion, choice of dressing
- Kale Caesar$12.95Kale, parmesan, Caesar dressing, and rye croutons. Add anchovy for no additional charge
- Wedge Salad$8.45Iceberg wedge, bacon, crumbled bleu cheese, tomatoes, scallions, and choice of dressing
- Apricot Brie Salad$12.95Mixed greens, balsamic vinaigrette, dried apricot, crumbled Brie, toasted walnuts, and grilled onions
- Cobb Salad$14.95Mixed greens, chicken, egg, tomatoes, bacon, crumbled bleu cheese, and avocado
burgers
All burgers served with lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle, and choice of side
- Mac Daddy Burger$14.95Scotch Egg, Swiss, creamy sage sauce
- A Proper Burger$11.95Cheddar, bacon, sautéed onions, special sauce
- Plant Based Burger$12.95Topped with your choice of cheese
- Improper burger$12.95Ghost pepper cheese, jalapeño, and banana peppers with parsley aioli
- Mac Burger$11.95Bacon, Swiss cheese and coleslaw
- Build Your Own$9.95Choose Ohio-raised ground beef or Ohio-raised natural chicken breast; lettuce, tomatoes, red onion. | Additional toppings 75¢ each: Bacon, coleslaw, onion rings, sautéed onions, sautéed mushrooms, Swiss, cheddar, Havarti, bleu cheese, feta, American, pepper jack, ghost pepper. | Add avocado $1.50
sandwiches
All sandwiches served with your choice of side
- Fish Sandwich$12.95Hand-battered cod, cheddar cheese, coleslaw, tartar sauce
- Pot Roast Sandwich$13.95Slow-cooked pot roast, mushrooms, onions, and potatoes on a hoagie roll
- Portabella$10.95Balsamic grilled portabella, lettuce, tomatoes, red pepper, and Havarti
- Spicy Black Bean Veggie Burger$10.95Black beans, whole kernel corn, tomatoes, and mild green chile peppers
- Tuna Melt$10.95Housemade tuna salad with Swiss on Texas toast
- Reuben$13.95Housemade corned beef, Swiss, sauerkraut, Russian dressing, on swirl rye. Rachel style: Turkey and coleslaw
- Triple Decker Club$13.95Oven-roasted turkey, bacon, smoked ham, American and Swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on Texas toast
- Mac’s Chicken Sandwich$11.95Grilled chicken, Havarti, chutney, and sautéed onions on Texas toast
- Italian Beef Sandwich$11.95Seared Italian beef, melted Havarti, and parsley aioli on a hoagie roll
- Mac's Triple Decker Grilled Cheese$10.95Melted Swiss, cheddar, Havarti, and bleu cheese with tomato on three slices of Texas toast
entrees
- Fish and Chips$16.95Hand-battered cod, Proper fries, coleslaw, and tartar sauce
- Bangers and Mash$17.95Classic recipe Irish bangers, scallion mashed potatoes, and onion gravy. Add eggs for $2.50
- Fire-Braised Flank Steak$19.95Served on a bed of white cheddar mac n' cheese topped with onion strings
- Shrimp Basket$16.95Hand-battered shrimp, Proper fries, coleslaw
- Atlantic Salmon$22.95Seared salmon, herbs, parsley aioli, red pepper, broccoli, and scallion mashed potatoes
- Steak and Chips$19.95Flat iron steak, Proper fries, parsley aioli, topped with onion strings
- Steak Pie$16.95Seasoned beef, onions, celery, carrots, beef gravy, pastry over mashed potatoes
sweets
- Mac’s Fudge Delight$6.95Chocolate brownie, vanilla ice cream, whipped cream, and chocolate sauce
- Bourbon Bread Pudding$8.95Brown sugar and bourbon brioche with ice cream and caramel sauce
sides
- Scallion Mashed Potatoes$3
- Onion Strings$3
- White Cheddar Mac and Cheese$3
- Mac's Proper Fries$3
- Coleslaw$3
- Broccoli$3
- Sautéed Kale$3
- Tater Tots$3
- House Salad$4.95
- Kale Caesar Salad$5.95
drinks
Pepsi / Diet Pepsi / Sierra Mist / Mountain Dew / Lemonade / Ginger Ale / Orange / Dr. Pepper / Proper Coffee / Iced Tea / Milk / Orange Juice / Cranberry Juice
taplist
Don't have your own growler? No worries. Take home a Mac's growler for just $10.
- Rhinegeist Truth$6.50
- Rhinegeist Peach Lodo$6.50
- Rhinegeist Cheetah$5.50
- Barley's Blonde Ale$6
- Madtree Lift Kolsch$6.50
- Thirsty Dog Lemon Shandy$6.50
- Saucy Brew B.F. Hefe$6.50
- Ace Cider$6.50
- Lost Coast Tangerine Wheat$6.50
- 3 Floyd’s Gumballhead Wheat Ale$7
- North High Rise$7
- Barley’s Bloodthirst Wheat Ale$7
- Barley’s Scottish Ale$7
- Guinness Stout$6.50
- Bell’s Two Hearted$7.50
- Rhinegeist Cloud Harvest Unfiltered Juicy IPA$7
- Heavy Seas TropiCannon Citrus IPA$7
- North High Yeoman Pilsner$6.50
- Taft's Jolly Melon Sour$6.50
- Taft's Nellie Key Lime Ale$6.50