Cakes

  • Angel Food Cake

    • Angel Food Cupcake
      These are an Underbrink's original. The cakes are fluffy and rich with a sweet buttercream icing.
      $3.65
      • Large Angel Food Cake
        These large cakes have the same fluffy texture as our famous cupcakes and can be bought with a seasonal design or designed to your needs. Popular for all occasions and are covered in a sweet buttercream icing. Custom designed angel food cakes start at $31.50.
        $28.50
        • Gluten Friendly Iced Angel Food Cupcake
          We took our famous, melt-in-your-mouth angel food cupcakes and made them GLUTEN FRIENDLY (not made in a separate kitchen). Iced with our delicious buttercream.
          $5.10

        • Specialty Cakes

          Call for prices on double layered cakes.

          • Boston Cream Pie Cake
            This is a buttery white cake that is filled with custard and topped with a chocolate glaze. (Single layer only)
            $51
            • Black Forrest Cake
              This is a chocolate cake with cherry/cream filling and more chocolate. (Single layer) Double Layer $59.50
              $49.50
              • Carrot Cake
                This is a soft, dense cake bursting with spicy carrot flavor. (Single Layer) Double Layer $54.50
                $39.50
                • German Chocolate Cake
                  This unique, dark chocolate flavored cake is topped with a coconut topping. (Single Layer) Double Layer $59.50
                  $49.50
                  • Strawberry Tall Cake
                    Our signature Large Angel Food Cake collides with our strawberry cream pie (minus the pie crust of course)!!
                    $35

                  • Birthday Cake

                    • 1/4 Sheet or 10" Single Round
                      Price increases with amount of decoration needed for the event. This will serve approx 12-16 people.
                      $41.50
                      • 1/2 Sheet
                        Price increases with amount of decoration needed for the event. This will serve approx 30 people.
                        $61.50
                        • Full Sheet
                          Price increases with the amount of decoration needed for the event. This will serve approx 62 people.
                          $100

                        • Round Double- Layered Cakes

                          • 10 inch Round
                            Price increases with the amount of decoration needed for the event. This will serve between 12 and 20 people. Double Layer: $56.50
                            $41.50
                            • 12 inch Round
                              Price increase with amount of decoration needed for the event. This will serve approx 28 people. Double Layer: $67
                              $46
                              • 6"- 8"-10" Tiered Cake
                                This is the base price & increases with amount of decoration needed for the event.
                                $165

                              • Cupcakes

                                • Classic Flavored Cupcake
                                  Vanilla, Red Velvet, Chocolate, German Chocolate & Carrot
                                  $4.55
                                  • Gluten-Friendly Chocolate Cupcake
                                    Extremely rich and gooey Gluten-Friendly Chocolate Cupcake iced with our delicious buttercream or cream cheese. Made with cocoa and dark chocolate.
                                    $4.10

                                  • Wedding Cakes

                                    We have decided to go in a different direction regarding WEDDING CAKES. While we would love to stay a part of helping couples create their magical day, we have decided to take a step back from multi-tiered wedding cakes and delivery to the event. If sheet cakes, cupcakes and/or angel food cakes/cupcakes are something you would be interested in for your wedding, we would love to make that happen, as long as they are picked up from the bakery. We are no longer delivering wedding cakes. **If we already have a wedding date confirmed and deposit accepted for your big day, please know that we will honor these orders! It has been a transition for us, navigating someone else’s ideas and notes, but we will be in contact to make sure everyone is on the same page before the big day! Feel free to email our extremely-talented and experienced decorator, directly at underbrinkscakes@yahoo.com