• Flavors
  • Cake Orders
  • Novelties
  • To Go Menu

Flavors

  • Ice Cream Flavors

    Our ice cream is homemade daily in the shoppe, because of this please know that our flavors rotate daily. To check if we have specific flavor in stock please give us a call!

    • Vanilla
      Vanilla
      Slightly different from your traditional vanilla, we use a bourbon vanilla extract to create our one of a kind vanilla ice cream. Our vanilla is always in stock!
        Gluten Free
      • Chocolate
        Chocolate
        Velvet rich chocolate. Our chocolate is always in stock!
          Gluten Free
        • Strawberry
          Strawberry
          Get a delicious bite of real strawberry in every spoonful. Our Strawberry is always in stock!
          • Cookie Dough
            Cookie Dough
            With a small amount of chocolate fudge mixed into our base and a cookie dough bites in every spoonful, our Cookie Dough flavor stands out above the rest. Our Cookie Dough is always in stock!
            • Strawberry Cheesecake
              Our classic Cheesecake base with NY Cheesecake chunks and Strawberries. This flavor rotates.
              • Cookie Monster
                Cookie Monster
                A favorite amongst the kids, we put a little spin on the classic cookies a cream. Our Cookie Monster is always in stock!
                • Chocolate Peanut Butter Overload
                  Chocolate Peanut Butter Overload
                  A combination of Chocolate Ice Cream, Peanut butter cups, and Peanut butter sauce makes this one of our most popular ice cream flavors. Our Chocolate Peanut Butter Overload is always in stock!
                  • Vanilla Peanut Butter Swirl
                    Vanilla Peanut Butter Swirl
                    A combination of Vanilla ice cream, peanut butter sauce and Reese's Pieces create this delicious flavor. Our Vanilla Peanut Butter Swirl is always in stock.
                    • Cherry Vanilla
                      A traditional Vanilla Ice Cream with Bordeaux Cherries in every spoonful. Our Cherry Vanilla Ice Cream is always in stock!
                      • Mint Chocolate Chip
                        • Coffee
                          • Birthday Cake
                            • Maple Walnut
                              • Moose Tracks
                                • Butter Pecan
                                  • No Sugar Added Vanilla
                                  • Water Ice

                                    We also hand make wonderful flavors of water ice!

                                    • Strawberry & Banana Gelato
                                        Vegetarian VeganGluten Free
                                      • Piña Colada
                                        • Cherry
                                          • Cotton Candy
                                            • Root Beer
                                              • Blue Raspberry
                                                • Bubble Gum
                                                  • Lemon
                                                  • Flavors
                                                  • Cake Orders
                                                  • Novelties
                                                  • To Go Menu
                                                  Please place your order 48 hours in advance of pick-up time. If you would like to include an edible printed version of a design you like to be put on the top of your cake, be sure to email the picture to Cherryontopmullicahill@gmail.com

                                                  Cake Orders

                                                  • Ice Cream Cakes

                                                    • 6" Round Cake
                                                      6" Round Cake
                                                      6 inches of soft serve ice cream with cake crunch in the middle. Be sure to include your choice of icing colorant any messages you would like added in the "Special Requests" section of the order form.
                                                      $22
                                                      • Chocolate
                                                      • Vanilla
                                                      • Hard Dip
                                                    • 9" Round Cake
                                                      9" Round Cake
                                                      9 inches of soft serve ice cream with cake crunch in the middle. Be sure to include your choice of icing colorant any messages you would like added in the "Special Requests" section of the order form.
                                                      $27
                                                      • Vanilla
                                                      • Chocolate
                                                      • Hard Dip
                                                    • Full Sheet Cake
                                                      Full Sheet Cake
                                                      A 18" x 24" of soft serve ice cream with cake crunch in the middle. Be sure to include your choice of icing color and any messages you would like added in the "Special Requests" section of the order form.
                                                      $37
                                                      • Chocolate Cake Crunch
                                                      • Vanilla Cake Crunch
                                                      • Vanilla Cake
                                                        ...................................................................................................
                                                        $8
                                                      • Chocolate Cake
                                                        ...................................................................................................
                                                        $8
                                                      • M&M's
                                                        ...................................................................................................
                                                        $1
                                                      • Oreo Cookies
                                                        ...................................................................................................
                                                        $1
                                                      • Other
                                                        ...................................................................................................
                                                        $1
                                                  • Seasonal Cakes

                                                    Here you can find and order our seasonal specialty cakes

                                                    • Mother's Day Flower Basket Cake
                                                      A basket full of flowers for Mom! Choose from our ice cream flavors and what color flowers!
                                                      • Chocolate
                                                      • Vanilla
                                                      • Hard Dip
                                                    • CupCake Flower Bouquet
                                                      A pull-apart cake in the beautiful design of a bouquet of flowers for mom! Choose your ice cream flavors and flower designs!~
                                                      • Chocolate
                                                      • Vanilla
                                                      • Hard Dip
                                                  • Ice Cream Pies

                                                    Each pie order can be made from any of our standard flavors, and with any fruit topping of your choice.

                                                    • Seasonal Pie
                                                      Seasonal Pie
                                                      Delicious Seasonal Pies made fresh in our Shoppe! Pre order yours today to bring something different to your next Holiday Gathering!
                                                      $15
                                                      • Ginger Snap Crust (Ginger snap Crust)
                                                      • Pumpkin Pie (Graham Cracker Crust)
                                                      • Apple Pie (Graham Cracker Crust)
                                                      • Peppermint Pie (Oreo Cookie Crust)
                                                      • Pecan Pie (Pecan Crust) *Additional $5.00
                                                        ...................................................................................................
                                                        $5
                                                      • Cheesecake (Graham Cracker Crust)
                                                      • Other (Please fill in special request section for flavor request)
                                                    • Ice Cream Cheesecake
                                                      Choose any of our cheesecake flavored ice creams and then any of our fruit toppings.
                                                      $11.95
                                                      • Oreo Crust
                                                      • Graham Cracker Crust
                                                  • Flavors
                                                  • Cake Orders
                                                  • Novelties
                                                  • To Go Menu

                                                  Novelties

                                                  • Hand Made Novelties

                                                    • Ice Cream Sandwiches
                                                      Ice Cream Sandwiches
                                                      $7.95
                                                      • Macaron 6 Pack
                                                        Macaron 6 Pack
                                                        $7
                                                          VegetarianGluten Free
                                                        • Macaron Sandwich
                                                          Macaron Sandwich
                                                          $3.95
                                                            VegetarianGluten Free
                                                        • Flavors
                                                        • Cake Orders
                                                        • Novelties
                                                        • To Go Menu
                                                        Looking to have Cherry On Top Delivered to your home? We are now on door dash! Use this menu to order all your favorites to go.

                                                        To Go Menu