The pizzas at "Lakeshore" Teresa's Deli have been around for over 30 years. The pizza's are still made the old fashion way, with homemade ingredients. Crusts are allowed to rise and carefully roll out. Homemade Pizza sauce is ladled onto the pizza and only the best and freshest available ingredients - from the sweet Italian sausage to the most flavorful red peppers - are placed on top. Whether you want the pizza "hot and ready to eat", par-baked to "finish up when you get home" or frozen for a later date… these pizzas are 100% pure quality.
Pizza (all prices shown are Cash/Check only)
Create Your Own (All Prices Shown are Cash/Check only)
- Thin and Crispy Pizza
- Small...................................................................................................$11.59
- Additional Toppings List...................................................................................................$1.49
- Large...................................................................................................$14.79
- Additional Toppings...................................................................................................$2.29
- Thick and Chewy Pizza
- Small...................................................................................................$12.19
- Additional Toppings...................................................................................................$1.49
- Large...................................................................................................$15.99
- Additional Toppings List...................................................................................................$2.29
- *Additional Chicken Toppings...
- Large...................................................................................................$3.99
- Small...................................................................................................$2.99
- Anchovies Toppings are always$2.99
- Additional Toppings ListPepperoni, Mushrooms, Onions, Blk Olives, Banana Peppers, Green Peppers, Broccoli, Jalapenos, Ham, Salami, Sausage, Meatball, Steak, Pineapple, Tomatoes, And the list goes on...
Specialty Pizzas (all prices shown are Cash/Check only)
- Steak and Cheese with MushroomsPremium shavings of roast beef simmering in a beef au jus broth topped with mushrooms and mozzarella cheese with your choice of our homemade red pizza sauce or our olive oil white base sauce
- Small-Thin...................................................................................................$12.99
- Small-Thick...................................................................................................$13.99
- Large-Thin...................................................................................................$18.99
- Large-Thick...................................................................................................$19.99
- Chicken RanchBreaded whole muscle chicken is the start! Your choice of several different combinations of toppings and red or white sauce
- Small-Thin...................................................................................................$12.99
- Small-Thick...................................................................................................$13.99
- Large-Thin...................................................................................................$19.99
- Large-Thick...................................................................................................$20.99
- Bacon, Lettuce, and Tomato
- Small-Thin...................................................................................................$12.49
- Small-Thick...................................................................................................$13.99
- Large-Thin...................................................................................................$18.99
- Large-Thick...................................................................................................$19.99
- White SicilianOur olive oil white base sauce tipped with fresh sliced onions and tomatoes sprinkled with a verity of seasonings and topped with mozzarella cheese
- Small-Thin...................................................................................................$12.49
- Small-Thick...................................................................................................$12.99
- Large-Thin...................................................................................................$16.99
- Large-Thick...................................................................................................$17.99
- Meat Lovers / Veggie Lovers
- Small-Thin...................................................................................................$16.99
- Small-Thick...................................................................................................$17.99
- Large-Thin...................................................................................................$24.99
- Large-Thick...................................................................................................$26.99
Party Pizza (all prices shown are Cash/Check only)
16" X 24" Party Pizza cut in 20, 30, or 40 pieces
- Cheese and One Item$29.99
- Each Additional Item....
- AdditionalToppings...................................................................................................$3.99
- Chicken Toppings...................................................................................................$4.99
We are absolutely legendary for our sub sandwiches, especially for our 2lb. King Combo! Our submarine sandwich has earned it's place in hearts throughout the Erie area. What makes "Lakeshore" Teresa's Deli's sub sandwiches so terrific? The secret is in the sub! We start with the highest quality meats and cheeses. Add lettuce and tomatoes. Even our bread is baked fresh daily. But what really sets us apart is that each and every submarine sandwich is made fresh to order. Meats and cheeses are sliced fresh for each submarine sandwich, and piled high on the baked bread right before the eyes of the customers. You'll never find stale, pre-prepared “set-ups” at "Lakeshore" Teresa's Deli. Everything is quickly made to order for each and every customer.
Subs, Salads, Wings
Famous Subs (all prices shown are Cash/Check only)
Add any additional items such as hot peppers, mushrooms, black olives, etc. If you add extra items on subs .99-small 1.59-medium, 1.69-large per item on each sub.
- CombinationPremium slices of ham, salami, capicol, mozzarella cheese topped off with lettuce sliced tomato and your choice of mayo or our house dressing
- Small...................................................................................................$8.99
- Medium...................................................................................................$11.99
- Large...................................................................................................$14.99
- Combo NightmareAll of the premium slices of ham salami capicol and mozzarella cheese along with pepperoni, banana peppers, onions, mushrooms and believe it or not extra, cheese topped off with lettuce sliced tomatoes and choice of dressing
- Small...................................................................................................$11.59
- Medium...................................................................................................$14.49
- Large...................................................................................................$16.89
- Chicken & CheddarBreaded whole muscle chicken filets topped with sharp cheddar lettuce sliced tomato and choice of dressing
- Small...................................................................................................$10.99
- Medium...................................................................................................$14.49
- Large...................................................................................................$16.89
- Chicken Bacon ClubBreaded whole muscle chicken filets topped with Swiss cheese, bacon, lettuce, sliced tomato and choice of dressing
- Small...................................................................................................$12.49
- Medium...................................................................................................$15.49
- Large...................................................................................................$17.89
- Grilled Chicken CheddarGrilled whole muscle chicken filets topped with sharp cheddar lettuce sliced tomato and choice of dressing
- Small...................................................................................................$12.89
- Medium...................................................................................................$16.29
- Large...................................................................................................$19.89
- Grilled Chicken Bacon ClubGrilled whole muscle chicken filets topped with Swiss cheese, bacon, lettuce, sliced tomato and choice of dressing
- Small...................................................................................................$13.99
- Medium...................................................................................................$18.19
- Large...................................................................................................$19.89
- Chicken Salad - White BreastsWhite Pulled Chicken breast meat mixed in mayo celery and seasonings
- Small...................................................................................................$12.49
- Medium...................................................................................................$14.49
- Large...................................................................................................$16.79
- Bacon, Lettuce, and TomatoJust what it says only in heavy quantities of each topped off with heavy mayo
- Small...................................................................................................$10.99
- Medium...................................................................................................$13.49
- Large...................................................................................................$15.69
- Crab SaladImitation Crab chunks smothered in mayo along with celery and seasonings.
- Small...................................................................................................$11.79
- Medium...................................................................................................$14.99
- Large...................................................................................................$16.99
- Pizza SubJust like a pizza only on a sub roll consisting of too much sauce mozzarella cheese and pepperoni
- Small...................................................................................................$9.49
- Medium...................................................................................................$12
- Large...................................................................................................$14.99
- Ham & CheesePremium slices of Hormel Ham and Mozzarella cheese topped with lettuce sliced tomato and choice of dressing
- Small...................................................................................................$8.99
- Medium...................................................................................................$11.99
- Large...................................................................................................$14.99
- BBQ Ham & CheesePremium ham slices drenched in our open pit barbecue sauce smothered with mozzarella cheese
- Small...................................................................................................$9.99
- Medium...................................................................................................$13.49
- Large...................................................................................................$16.79
- Veggie MeltBlack olives, mushrooms, greenpeppers, onions smothered in mozzarella cheese topped off with lettuce sliced tomato and choice of dressing
- Small...................................................................................................$9.89
- Medium...................................................................................................$13.19
- Large...................................................................................................$16.79
- Tuna MeltOur "made here" premium tuna salad with onions, eggs, celery, herbs, and spices melted on our homemade bread with tons of mozzarella cheese
- Small...................................................................................................$9.99
- Medium...................................................................................................$13.49
- Large...................................................................................................$16.89
- Meatball & CheeseSlabs of momma’s homemade meatballs drenched in her spaghetti sauce and smothered with mozzarella cheese
- Small...................................................................................................$10.99
- Medium...................................................................................................$14.69
- Large...................................................................................................$16.99
- Meatball NightmareYour dreams come true with our homemade meatball slabs smothered with mozzarella cheese, pepperoni, onions, banana peppers, and mushrooms and believe it or not extra cheese!
- Small...................................................................................................$12.49
- Medium...................................................................................................$16.89
- Large...................................................................................................$18.69
- Sausage & CheeseA mix of mild and zesty Sausage smothered in Spaghetti sauce and mozzarella cheese
- Small...................................................................................................$10.99
- Medium...................................................................................................$14.69
- Large...................................................................................................$16.99
- Sausage, Peppers & OnionA mix of mild and zesty sausage topped with fresh cut green peppers and onions
- Small...................................................................................................$10.99
- Medium...................................................................................................$14.69
- Large...................................................................................................$16.99
- Turkey & CheesePremium slices of oven roasted turkey and mozzarella cheese topped with lettuce slice tomato and choice of dressing
- Small...................................................................................................$10.99
- Medium...................................................................................................$13.49
- Large...................................................................................................$15.99
- Turkey Ham ClubPremium slices of oven roasted turkey Hormel Ham topped with mozzarella or your choice of cheese and as always lettuce sliced tomatoes and choice of dressing
- Small...................................................................................................$10.99
- Medium...................................................................................................$13.79
- Large...................................................................................................$16.29
- Steak, Cheese & MushroomPremium shavings of roast beef simmering in a beef au jus broth topped with mushrooms mozzarella cheese lettuce sliced tomato and choice of dressing
- Small...................................................................................................$11.99
- Medium...................................................................................................$15.19
- Large...................................................................................................$18.29
- Chicken ParmesanBreaded whole muscle chicken patty topped with our homemade spaghetti sauce and mozzarella cheese
- Small...................................................................................................$11.39
- Medium...................................................................................................$14.49
- Large...................................................................................................$16.99
- Eggplant ParmesanSliced eggplant battered and baked topped with our homemade spaghetti sauce and mozzarella cheese
- Small...................................................................................................$11.39
- Medium...................................................................................................$14.49
- Large...................................................................................................$16.99
Sliders (prices shown are Cash/Check only)
- Combo$4.99
- Meatball$5.29
- Pizza$4.99
Salads (prices shown are Cash/Check only)
- Antipasto SaladFresh and Loaded by the pound (1 3/4 lb.)$12.49
- Potato Salad - by the poundMom's Homemade$8.20
- Macaroni Salad - by the poundMom's Homemade$8.20
- Chef SaladSwiss, turkey, ham, and American cheese with hard boiled egg throughout by the pound (1 3/4 lb.)$12.99
- Breaded Chicken SaladBreaded chicken, bacon, hard boiled egg, tomatoes, sliced olives *Cajun seasoned if desired$13.99
- Grilled Chicken SaladGrilled Chicken, bacon, hard boiled egg, tomatoes, sliced olives *Cajun seasoned if desired$14.69
Chicken Wings and Fingers (prices shown are Cash/Check only)
Available in Mild (BBQ), Medium, Hot, Butter & Garlic, and Cajun Flavors. Our sauces are homemade!
- Chicken WingsFlappers and Drumsticks baked not deep fried with your choice of sauces both wet and dry!
- 8...................................................................................................$7.95
- 12...................................................................................................$11.95
- 18...................................................................................................$17.95
- 24...................................................................................................$23.95
- 36...................................................................................................$34.99
- Chicken FingersBreaded whole muscle chicken filet tenders baked not deep fried with your choices of sauce
- 8...................................................................................................$8.99
- 12...................................................................................................$13.99
- 18...................................................................................................$20.99
- 24...................................................................................................$28.99
- 36...................................................................................................$40.99
Dinners (all prices shown are Cash/Check only)
Italian Dinners
- LasagnaOne pound of lasagna with tossed salad and garlic bread$14.89
- Stuffed ShellsThree extra large shells stuffed with Ricotta cheese, two meatballs, salad, and garlic bread$14.99
- Rigatoni & MeatballsRigatoni, two meatballs, salad, and garlic bread$13.99
- RavioliOne half pound meat or cheese raviolis, salad, two meatballs, and garlic bread$13.89
- Chicken Parmesan3/4 pound chicken, a side of rigatoni, salad, and garlic bread$14.89
- Eggplant ParmesanOne pound eggplant, salad, and garlic bread$13.89
- Calzone5 Items with Crazy Bread and Sauce on the Side$13.99
- Family BucketRigatoni, Meatballs, Antipasto Salad, Garlic Bread (Serves 4)$29.99
Other Goodies (all prices shown are Cash/Check only)
- Celery & Carrots$4.99
- Pepperoni Balls (3)$5.69
- Crazy Bread with Sauce$5.79
- Other "GOODIES"Variety of "Delicious" Cheese Cakes, Huge Cookies, "To Die for" Homemade Brownies, Pastas, Sauces, Frozen Entrees and a Full Line of Imported and Domestic Deli Meats and Cheeses
Daily Specials (all prices shown are Cash/Check only)
Daily Specials
- Everyday Special #12 lb King Combo & Antipasto$25.99
- Everyday Special #2Large 2 Item Thin Pizza & 2 lb Combo$27.79
- Monday10" Combo & 12 oz Pop$9.59
- TuesdayAntipasto & Garlic Bread$11.99
- WednesdayRigatoni & Meatballs Dinner$12.99
- ThursdayLarge 2 Item Thin & Crispy Pizza$15.99
- ThursdayLarge 2 Item Thick & Chewy Pizza$16.99
- Friday18" 2 lb King Combo, 6 Pepperoni Balls, and 6 Pack of Pop$30.99
- Saturday/Sunday"Homemade" Ravioli or Lasagna Dinner$12.99
Our Most Popular menu: $14.99 per person for parties of 20 or more! Pick any 3 meats, poultry, or fish and any 2 side dishes. "Homemade Rolls" and butter "included"! On-site pleasant management is available along with paper ware, beverage service and all your catering needs. Packages from $11.99-$28.00 pp.-Call John at 814-434-0400 for more information!
2019 and 2023 People's Choice
Catering Menu (all prices shown are Cash/Check only)
Meat, Poultry, and Fish
- Aunt Rosey's Chicken - Roasted or BBQOnly select Grade A Drums & Thighs roasted that day by my Aunt using our family's recipe. (serving portion = 1+ per person) (add chicken breast for a minimal cost)
- Sausage with Peppers and OnionsHomemade & mixed with fresh bell peppers and onions.
- Huge MeatballsMade by my mother, Grace, covered in her homemade spaghetti sauce. (serving portion = 1½ per person)
- Ox RoastSliced premium roast beef in our tangy au jus and a touch of onions throughout.
- Gourmet HamSmith's Gourmet baked with sliced pineapple.
- BBQ Pulled Pork or "Ribs on the Bone**"Juicy and tender & loaded with sauce. **Due to market conditions please add $1/person when selecting Ribs
- Homemade MeatloafMom's special recipe.
- Broiled Alaskan Pollock5 oz. portion sautéed in our recipe of herbs & spices.
Side Dishes
- RigatoniImported Bozza ribbed pasta cooked al'dante in mom's homemade sauce so they're nice and firm when ready to serve.
- Macaroni, Potato or Broccoli SaladAll are homemade and delicious.
- Antipasto SaladFresh Greens (Romaine & Iceberg) Loaded with premium meats & cheeses and our famous Homemade Italian & Ranch dressings on the side.
- Tossed SaladFresh Greens (Romaine & Iceberg) loaded with veggies & cheese. With our homemade Italian & Ranch dressings on the side!
- Chef SaladFresh Greens (Romaine & Iceberg) Swiss, turkey, bacon and hard boiled egg throughout.
- Cheesy PotatoesShredded potatoes with a blend of melted cheese throughout.
- Scallop or Roasted PotatoesAunt Rosey's famous touch using only the A-red potatoes.
- Baked BeansCooked old-style.
- Mixed Veggies or Green BeansFresh and seasoned to perfection.
- Green Bean CasseroleGreen Beans in a rich mushroom sauce topped off with French fried onions.
- Macaroni and CheeseOur homemade "3 CHEESE" timeless favorite.
- Mash Potatoes & GravyAunt Rosey’s hand whipped real potato buds with her homemade gravy.
- Wedding SoupFresh & delicious.
- Fried RiceDelicious Fried Rice with Egg and Veggies
Party Trays (all prices shown are Cash/Check only)
- Meat & Cheese TraySliced for sandwiches or cubed for finger snacks: 16” Trays beautifully decorated with our finest “Imported & Domestic” meats and cheeses such as: Krakus Ham, Dilussio Genoa Salami, The Leanest cut Breast of Turkey, Enrico Provolone, Natural Swiss and Circle U Pepperoni garnished and decorated with our aged Italian Olives. Feeds 20-45 people. $35-$65 depending on selections
- Fresh Veggie TrayHomegrown seasonal produce “Hand Picked” such as: Bell Peppers, Carrots, Celery, Cherry Tomatoes, Broccoli, Cauliflower, Cucumbers with our Buttermilk Ranch. Feeds 30-40 people.$57
- Fresh Fruit TrayTruly “Hand Picked” that day Pineapple, Watermelon, Strawberries, Grapes, Cantaloupe and Kiwi with our own “Strawberry Dip”.$79.99
- Italian Platter*Marinated salads such as: Artichoke Hearts, Mushrooms, Peppers stuffed with Prosciutto & Provolone, Roasted Red Peppers and Sweet Tortellini (when available), Aged Black & Green Olives centered with delicious chunks of imported Fontinella Cheese. *Market Price*
- Sub PlatterConsists of 24 wedge cut of premium cold cuts.$48
- Wrap or Croissant PlatterYour choice of premium salad spreads or cold cuts.$50
- Calzone Tray40-50ct. 1” x 4” strips of fresh dough calzone filled with Ham, Salami, Pepperoni, Ricotta and Mozzarella Cheese and your choice of dip.$57
- Shrimp TrayHuge 21-25 count SIZE peeled & de-veined with lemons centered around our "Homemade" cocktail sauce
- 50 Shrimp Count...................................................................................................$60
- 90 Shrimp Count...................................................................................................$110
- Meat & Cheese Cube or Sliced & Cheese/Pepperoni Cracker TrayA variety of Meats and Cheeses both imported & domestic cubed with pepperoni chunks in the middle. Feeds 20-45 people. $35-$65 depending on selections
Other Popular Entrees (all prices shown are Cash/Check only)
- 8oz. Stuffed Chicken Breast "on the Bone"8 once fresh chicken breast on the bone with homemade stuffing*** ***-When Available ***Market Price
- Homemade Lasagna-Meat or Veggie
- 24 cuts...................................................................................................$93
- 12 cuts...................................................................................................$49
- Mom's from scratch Alfredo Sauce
- Taco Bar.....$13.99 per person includes a variety of soft taco shells. Seasoned Chicken and Beef, Tomatoes, Onions, Cheese & Jalapeno toppings. Spanish Rice, Chips & Salsa/Taco sauce/Queso Cheese Dip/Hot Sauce
- Other Dishes.....Stuffed Shells, Meat or Cheese Ravioli, Pasta Salad.... You want it? We'll Make It!!