ONLINE ORDERING

  • PIES

    Create your own Cookie Dough Ice Cream Pies! Choose from our available Cookie Dough and Ice Cream options and select your favorite toppings. We will have it ready for pickup in 48 hours.

    • Chocolate Chip Pie
      Chocolate Chip Dough Crust, Vanilla Ice Cream, Chocolate Chips, M&M's, and Chocolate Sauce
      $13
      • CUSTOM PIE
        Create your own custom pie with the available Ice Cream and Cookie Dough flavors. Do not forget to select your toppings!
        $13
        • Chocolate Chips
        • Salted Caramel Chips
        • White Chocolate Chips
        • Oreo's
        • Brownie Bits
        • Chocolate Sprinkles
        • Rainbow Sprinkles
        • Peppermint
        • Chopped Nuts
        • Butterfinger
        • Peanut Butter Cups
        • Pineapple
        • Coconut Flakes
        • Cherries
        • Reese's Pieces
        • M & M's
        • Gummy Worms
        • Swedish Fish
        • Caramel Sauce
        • Peanut Butter Sauce
        • Marshmallow Sauce
        • Chocolate Sauce
        • Strawberry Sauce
        • Wet Walnuts

    Flavors

    • <<< COOKIE DOUGH FLAVORS >>>

      Made in house at Dough & Arrows Flavors availability will change daily.

      • CHOCOLATE CHIP
        Mini Chocolate Chips
        • BROWNIE BATTER
          Delicious brownie batter with chocolate chips
          • COOKIES & CREAM
            If you love an Oreo you will fall in love with cookies and cream dough.
            • SALTED CARAMEL
              A mix of sea salt and caramel chips will leave you feeling salty and sweet.
              • SUGAR COOKIES
                Sugar cookie style dough topped off with some colorful sprinkles
                • PEANUT BUTTER
                  Peanut butter dough
                  • BASIC BATCH
                    Some things are just better BASIC...just plain DOUGH!
                    • COOKIE MONSTER
                      A Kid Favorite!

                    • <<< ICE CREAM FLAVORS >>>

                      From Penn State Creamery Flavors availability will change daily.

                      • COFFEE BREAK
                        coffee ice cream, chocolate chips
                        • STRAWBERRY
                          vanilla ice cream, strawberries
                          • PEANUT BUTTER
                            vanilla ice cream, peanut butter swirl
                            • PEACHY PATERNO
                              peach ice cream, peach slices
                              • HAPPY HAPPY JOY JOY
                                coconut ice cream, butter-roasted almonds, chocolate chips
                                • BITTERSWEET MINT
                                  mint ice cream, chocolate chips
                                  • DEATH BY CHOCOLATE
                                    chocolate ice cream, chocolate flakes, fudge pieces, chocolate swirl
                                    • VANILLA
                                      • COOKIES & CREAM
                                        vanilla ice cream, Oreo cookies
                                        • CHOCOLATE CHIP COOKIE DOUGH
                                          cookie dough ice cream, cookie dough chunks, chocolate chips

                                        Ice Cream