Extraordinary Cupcakes

  • Monday - Saturday

    Monday - Saturday

    • Remarkable Red Velvet
      Classic red cake with cream cheese icing 4.95
    • Uncommon Carrot
      Moist cake with fresh grated carrots, crushed pineapple, walnuts and Vietnamese cinnamon and a cream cheese icing. 4.95
    • Marvelous Madagascar
      Our best seller! We make this traditional pound cake with Madagascar Vanilla, from the island of Madagascar. Yes, it is a pound cake so it is a dense vanilla bean cake with Madagascar Vanilla buttercream icing. 5.45
    • Wicked Chocolate
      Rich chocolate cake topped with rich chocolate icing. 4.95
    • Fantastic Chocolate Flip
      Our Wicked chocolate cake – with Madagascar Vanilla buttercream icing. 4.95
    • Fantastic Vanilla Flip
      Our Marvelous Vanilla cake – with rich Wicked chocolate icing 4.95
    • Phenomenal Peanut Butter
      Wicked Chocolate cake, creamy peanut butter filling, peanut butter buttercream icing. 5.45
    • Gluten Free Cupcakes
      We are excited to use Chef Thomas Keller’s Gluten Free C4C Flour. We offer 2 flavors of gluten free cake - vanilla and chocolate. We customize your cupcakes with your choice of icing and filling. 5.95 unfilled 6.45 filled
    • Now available daily - Luscious Lemon Raspberry
      A moist lemon cake filled with rich Raspberry compound and topped with a Raspberry buttercream icing. 5.45
    • ALL AUTUMN LONG - Sensational S'Mores
      Chocolate cake, marshmallow, graham cracker and chocolate filling covered in milk chocolate and topped off with an Extraordinary sized toasted marshmallow!
    • September - Awesome Almond Blackberry
      Moist almond cake is filled with sweet blackberry puree, then it's topped with a Blackberry Buttercream & white chocolate!
    • Strawberry Shortcake Push Pop
      Layers of Madagascar icing, fresh cut strawberries, and vanilla cake. Delicious! Ready and waiting for you in the grab and go fridge inside Illy Caffe Williamsburg.

  • Our Monthly & Seasonal Specials!

    • ALL WINTER LONG - Gregarious German Chocolate
      Super-light chocolate cake with a pecan & coconut caramel frosting and a rich coconut & pecan filling.
    • January - Miraculous Mint Cocoa
      Rich chocolate cake is filled with a fluffy mint cream and topped with a Vanilla/Mint Buttercream!
    • February - Ravishing Chocolate Raspberry
      Wicked Chocolate Cake filled with raspberry puree and iced with a raspberry buttercream frosting.
    • March - Brilliant Bananas Foster
      It just needs the ice cream! Rich banana cupcake with banana filling and a decadent caramel frosting.
    • May - Incredible Cookies and Cream
      marble swirled vanilla and chocolate cake with a decadent cookies and creme filling, topped with vanilla buttercream icing and crushed cookies.
    • August - Illustrious Key Lime
      A lime zest cake with key lime pastry cream filling topped with a fluffy icing & fresh lime zest!
    • September - Awesome Almond Blackberry
      Moist almond cake is filled with sweet blackberry puree, then it's topped with a Blackberry Buttercream & white chocolate!
    • October - Amazing Apple Brown Betty
      Moist spiced cake with baked apples, a soft vanilla frosting and a local Apple Butter Crumble!
    • November - The Great Pumpkin
      Vanilla cake with a dash of cinnamon, pumpkin pie filling and light cinnamon cream cheese frosting.
    • December - Wondrous Gingerbread
      gingerbread cake, topped with sweet cinnamon buttercream icing, adorned with a classic gingerbread man!
    • April - Tremendous Tres Leches
      An inspired creation that highlights soft vanilla and cream! A super moist 3 milk (drenched!) cake with a fluffy frosting. (Our thanks to Manny's mom at Kuba Kuba in Richmond for her inspirational cake!)
    • Bewitching Blueberry Lemon
      Soft Vanilla cake with local blueberries baked inside, a rich lemon custard filling and a Blueberry Cream Cheese icing - super delicious!
    • July - Impeccable Peaches & Cream
      A peach vanilla cake filled with peach and mascarpone, topped with a peach buttercream icing and a sprinkle of cinnamon sugar. 5.45
    • June 21 - September 20 Stupendous Strawberry Shortcake
      We puree locally grown, organic strawberries to fill this light vanilla cake, and top it off with a strawberry buttercream icing. Summer never tasted so good! 5.45

  • Not Cupcakes

    We don't just make cupcakes and cakes! We also make cheesecake, tiramisu, caramel apple bread pudding, mini cannoli, and many more. Call us to discuss the possibilities!.

    • OMG NY Cheesecake
      Super-Rich, extra tall Carnegie Deli style Cheesecake - because who does it better than Carnegie Deli? Each cheesecake takes hours and hours to make, but you get to enjoy it with no waiting!
    • Whoopie Pies
      It's tender Red Velvet cake with Cream Cheese filling stuffed inside - need we say more?
    • Walnut Mousse Bars
      Savory crushed walnuts on the bottom, smooth chocolate ganache and a layer of fluffy chocolate mousse to top it off!
    • Mom's Breathtaking Banana Pudding
      Sylvia gets all the credit for this one - but I can't imagine my childhood without it! Creamy pudding, vanilla wafers, sliced bananas - pure goodness! (Monday, Tuesday & Wednesday only!)