Gourmet Peanut Butter Cookies

  • Cookies Flavors

    Cookies Flavors

    Twelve varieties of our gourmet peanut butter cookies are sold individually at our retail store for $2 each or 12 for $20. Try them all!

    • Original
      Original
      The original no muss, no fuss cookie. There's no need for additional ingredients, this cookie stands on its own as the perfect peanut butter cookie.
      • Chocolate Chip
        Chocolate Chip
        The original cookie with semi-sweet chocolate chips added in for personality.
        • Chocolate Chip with Pecans
          Chocolate Chip with Pecans
          Chocolate Chip's nutty brother.
          • Dark Chocolate Chip
            Dark Chocolate Chip
            Chocolate Chip's more mysterious and interesting cousin. The subtle bitterness of the dark chocolate cuts the sweetness of the original base for the perfect combination of flavors.
            • English Toffee
              English Toffee
              Rich chocolate and buttery toffee are the perfect compliment to this cookie. Better than any cookie you'll find across the pond!
              • Salted Caramel
                Salted Caramel
                Shaved caramel is incorporated evenly into the original cookie. Hot from the oven, freshly ground pink Himalayan sea salt is sprinkled on top to create the perfect salty/sweet confection.
                • Salted Caramel Chocolate Chip
                  Salted Caramel Chocolate Chip
                  For those who have both chocolate and caramel at the top of the favorite flavor pyramid, this cookie is for you. The perfect chewy blend of salty and sweet is sure to please all cookie lovers.
                  • Caramel Peanut Crunch
                    Caramel Peanut Crunch
                    We took our salted caramel cookie and added peanut chunks. The surprising crunch in the chewiest cookie has quickly made this a fan favorite.
                    • Turtle
                      Turtle
                      Add pecans to our salted caramel chocolate chip cookie, and you have one incredible dessert. More substantial than its candy counterpart, this slow and steady cookie will have you winning races.
                      • PB & Strawberry Jelly
                        PB & Strawberry Jelly
                        America's favorite sandwich in cookie form. Take a trip back to your childhood and experience the perfect blend of peanut butter and strawberry jelly bits. Always excellent - amazing warm.
                        • PB & Grape Jelly
                          PB & Grape Jelly
                          PB&J lovers requested, and we delivered. This warm cookie has been described as "life changing." We think it compares to fresh baked blueberry muffins, but maybe that's because it makes us just that happy.
                          • M&M
                            M&M
                            Festive colors make this our happiest cookie. A favorite with children and adults alike, colors change to show enthusiasm for the next holiday.
                          • Cookie Trays

                            Hostess. Happy Birthday. House warming. Hump Day. Our cookie trays are perfect for any occasion - or no occasion at all.

                            • Caramel Lover's Tray
                              Six Salted Caramel, six Salted Caramel Chocolate Chip Cookies and 12 Salted Caramel candies.
                              $50
                              • Toffee Lover's Tray
                                18 English Toffee cookies with 1/2 pound English Toffee candy coated in milk chocolate and rolled in chopped almonds.
                                $50
                                • Variety Trays
                                  Variety Trays
                                  Each tray will contain an assortment of 6-12 flavors of our gourmet peanut butter cookies. 2 dozen-$36, 3 dozen-$54, 4 dozen-$72, 5 dozen-$90, 6 dozen-$108
                                  • Candy Trays
                                    Candy Trays
                                    Cookie and candy combo trays are popular gifts from sales executives for hosted luncheons and thank you gifts. Milk and Dark chocolate covered pretzels and salted caramels, and Almond Butter Crunch toffee will impress cookie and candy lovers alike.
                                  • Catering

                                    Cookie catering can be custom ordered to satisfy the cookie cravings of any size gathering.

                                    • Custom Orders
                                      Custom Orders
                                      When your party is larger than a tray will accommodate, a custom cookie order is the solution. Consider cookies for Weddings, Bar/Bat Mitzvah celebrations, and Graduation parties.