Jersey City

  • GET PIE

    Our delicious seasonal pies are available in several sizes. To make a custom order, send an email to pie@thepiesocial.com.

    • Orchard Apple Pie
      Orchard Apple Pie
      A delicious blend of tart-sweet apple varieties sourced locally and a flaky, buttery crust.
      $30
      • Strawberry Lemon Lattice
        Strawberry Lemon Lattice
        A classic with a twist! You can't go wrong with this party pleaser. Go ahead and pretend you made it yourself - we won't tell!
        $30
        • It's the Berries
          It's the Berries
          This blackberry and wild blueberry pie is filled with juicy berry goodness. It'll have you dancing the Charleston while shouting, "It's the berries!"
          $30
          • Old-Fashioned Pecan
            Old-Fashioned Pecan
            A pecan pie without corn syrup. We certainly don't miss it!
            $35
            • Salted Chocolate Chess
              Salted Chocolate Chess
              The Chess Pie has mysterious origins but most certainly comes from the South, where many great pies do! Our version is a perfect blend of chocolatey goodness with a hint of savory salt.
              $25
              • Kentucky Transparent
                Kentucky Transparent
                You guessed it! This pie hails from Kentucky and has the super sweet, buttery decadence to show for it. Let's see if you can eat just one piece!
                $25
                • Shaker Lemon
                  Shaker Lemon
                  This old-fashioned pie originated in the Shaker communities and is made with thinly sliced whole Meyer lemons - peel and all! The result is a glorious jammy filling of sunny lemons - sweet, tart, and a little bitter.
                  $25
                  • Pumpkin Noir
                    Pumpkin Noir
                    Not all pumpkin pies are created equal. This sultry twist on the traditional version has an intense caramel flavor and a shot of bourbon.
                    $25
                    • Bees Knees Honeypie
                      Bees Knees Honeypie
                      Made with wildflower honey, its smooth custard filling is finished with Maldon sea salt.
                      $25
                      • Want S'more Pie
                        Want S'more Pie
                        This campfire classic will be the only thing you'll want to snuggle up with this winter.
                        $30
                        • Triple Coconut Dream Pie
                          Triple Coconut Dream Pie
                          If you're nuts for coconut this creamy, dreamy pie will quickly become a family favorite! It's equal parts gooey, vanilla-flecked coconut custard and mounds of whipped cream on a coconut crust, topped off with a shower of toasted coconut flakes.
                          $30
                          • Heirloom Sour-Cream Raisin
                            Heirloom Sour-Cream Raisin
                            Eating a slice of this pie is like getting transported back in time. It’s a little bite of the past and one of those recipes we'd love to revive.
                            $25
                            • Buttermilk Chess
                              Buttermilk Chess
                              Buttermilk Pie hails from the UK, but is now a Southern favorite! This custard pie is the perfect dessert for an afternoon gathering or after dinner treat.
                              $25
                              • Chocolate Angel
                                Chocolate Angel
                                A meringue crust filled with chocolate cream and topped with a whipped cream cloud, you'd swear each bite was a slice of heaven.
                                $25
                                  Gluten Free
                                • Key Lime
                                  Key Lime
                                  A Florida native, Key Lime Pie is a summer favorite with its citrus tones and its smooth, cool filling. Take this pie to your next summer BBQ and be the hit of the party!
                                  $30